| |
Two theoretical models
| social reaction theories
| labeling |
| conflict |
|
| focus on the role that social and economic institutions play in producing
delinquents |
| the way society reacts to the individual |
Two important themes
| law and justice are differentially applied |
| involvement with justice system labels deviants |
Social Reaction
| The quality of the delinquent act is not so important as is the social
reaction to the act |
| The purpose of social control is to maintain the status quo. |
Labeling theory
| Delinquency is more of a process than a behavior
| behavior is not inherently bad |
|
| If a childs delinquency is discovered and labeled, that child is
likely to develop an identity as a delinquent and continue to act like one
| not an explanation for the onset of delinquent behavior |
|
Tannenbaum's "dramatization of evil"
| calling a child "delinquent", social typing transforms
offender's identity |
| child may internalize the description and live up to it |
| perennial suspects |
Lemert's labeling process
Primary deviance
| social reaction |
| self-conception |
Secondary deviance
| more social reaction |
| deviant identification complete |
Lemert effects
Institutionalization promotes recidivism.
Lower class
children are probably more likely to accept the label because of their
powerless and poverty
Howard Becker
| deviants are into homogeneous (falsely accused and secret deviants) |
| rules are created by moral entrepreneurs |
| commit a deviant act |
| get caught |
| acquire status |
| delinquency as master status |
Edwin Schur
| stereotyping rampant |
| inappropriate retrospective interpretation of youths |
| radical nonintervention |
| behavior is deviant only when it comes to the attention of people who
have the power to control undesirable behavior |
John Braithwaite
disintegrative shaming
| condemning juvenile |
| pushing into more delinquency |
reintegrative shaming
| condemnation of act |
| forgiveness and restoration |
Self-fulfilling prophecy
| label may be accepted by delinquent |
| behavior soon conforms to negative expectations |
| result is damaged self-image |
Chambliss
| "Saints" and "Roughnecks" |
| lower-status boys defined themselves as delinquents, while higher-status
boys saw themselves as engaging in pranks |
Evaluation of labeling theory
| Does not consistently find support for the idea that self-identification
changes once a deviant label applies. |
| Does not consistently find support for the idea that deviants already
have deviant identities and are not affected by labels. |
| Some support that labels increase recidivism. |
Heimer
| gender gap |
| meaning of behavior varies |
Discrimination in the labeling process
| young, male, minority members from lower economic class more likely to be
labeled |
| offenders with economic or political power are more likely to be given a
warning by the police |
| single-parent home related to discrimination |
| other research finds official processing influenced by offense
seriousness and prior record |
| police decisions influenced by prior record, association with known
delinquents, and drug involvement |
Labeling chronic offenders
| evidence that labeling amplifies deviant careers |
| experienced delinquents more likely to continue offending if viewed in a
negative light by significant others |
Criticism of labeling
| basic views too simplistic to form an accurate explanation |
| unlikely a label causes delinquency |
| too much emphasis on formal interaction |
| inherent evil |
Justice Programs
Schurs radical nonintervention
training schools were closed in Massachusetts in early 1970s
Diversion programs
Vision Quest, Outward Bound, wilderness programs, and Police Athletic
League
Social conflict theory
Conflict theorists focus on
| the roles social and governmental institutions play in creating and
enforcing laws |
| describing law as a social control mechanism |
Marxist thought
Thorsten Sellin
| crime norms are found in the law |
| conduct norms may directly conflict with them |
| heterogeneous and complex societies are likely to experience delinquency |
George Vold
| minority groups and the poor have little impact on the legislative
process |
| behaviors reflecting their interests are more likely to be legislated |
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels
| Civilization is determined by its mode of production |
| capitalism root of crime |
| repressive ruling class (bourgeoisie) to control the ruled class
(proletariat) produces delinquency |
Marxist theory
| part of human nature to work and be productive |
| crime result of demoralized working class through unemployment and
underemployment |
Mark Colvin and John Pauley
| workplace and the family are interrelated in capitalist societies |
| coercive control patterns of workplace and home produce delinquency |
Harold Pepinsky
| justice system perpetuates a cycle of violence which stems from a system
of upper-class domination |
| upper-class most likely to be violent |
| criminology of peacemaking |
| reduce crime by recognizing the political and economic sources of human
misery |
| see the relationship between human suffering and crime |
| reintegrate offenders back into their communities |
Regoli and Hewitts Differential Oppression
| delinquency is a culmination of a process |
| delinquents and the delinquencies are a product and adults are the
producers |
| adults pressure children to conform to their idea of "goodness"
and order |
Four Principles
| adults emphasize order in the home and school |
| adults see children as inferior, subordinate beings and as troublemakers |
| imposition of adult conceptions of order on children may become extreme
to the point of oppression |
| oppression leads to adaptive reactions by children |
Adaptive reactions
| passive acceptance (obedient out of fear) |
| exercise of illegitimate coercive power |
| manipulation of ones peers to gain power |
| retaliation (vandalism) |
Juvenile justice
| juvenile justice system may create and sustain delinquency |
| it is in the capitalist state's best interest to maintain a pool of
deviants |
Evaluations of conflict theory
| causal links of capitalism and crime are usually disproved |
| research connecting oppression and delinquency supports the link between
child abuse and delinquency |
Labeling, conflict and delinquency prevention
Important influence
| draw attention to system biases |
| the effects of system interaction on delinquency production |
Juvenile Justice Policy
| widespread discussion of the relationships between adults and children |
| rights of children addressed |
Labeling and conflict and Strain and control
| tend to side with adolescents in a critical examination of social power |
| question imbalances in social arrangements |
|
|