Catharsis: cf. Page 800, note two in the Norton anthology. Catharsis has two
definitions, one medical, one religious. Keep in mind that whether we understand catharsis
as religious purification or as medical purging, that the Greek tragedian expects the
audience (i.e. ourselves) to respond with a sense of pity and a sense of divine justice.
Question: Do the events of
The Eumenides result in a catharsis for the audience? Consider how we move from
concern for Orestes' plight to terror at the Furies' threats to his vindication before the
jury at Athens.
|
Hamartia:
The tragic hero undergoes great pain and suffering because she or he makes a mistake in
judgment or has a tragic flaw. Hamartia is also one of the Greek words the Apostle Paul
uses for describing the sin of humanity. Not all Greek heroes fall because of their sin;
some fall because they are trapped in unavoidable circumstances.
Question: What is the
tragic flaw of Orestes? Is he guilty of sin?
|
Hubris: Pride,
especially in attempting to go outside or beyond human knowledge, action, or capacity.
Often, hubris is a direct violation of the will of the gods.
Question: Does anyone
exhibit hubris in The Eumenides?
|
Spoken
and Sung Elements in Greek Tragedy |

|
[The material on spoken and sung elements
is optional material and not testable for our class purposes.]
Ancient Greek tragedy contains both prose
and poetry. Poetry was both spoken and sung.
Typical
sung elements:
1. Parodos: the opening ode sung by the chorus as they enter
the orchestra.
2. Stasima: ensemble songs
The Song of the Furies' Dance on pages 592-593 constitute
a typical stasima.
3. Hemechoria: songs divided between two portions of the
ensemble.
4. Monodia: songs sung by one actor
5. Diodia: songs sung by two actors in tandem or as a duet.
Typical
spoken elements:
1. Prologos: the opening
before the entrance of the chorus.
Pythia's opening prayer and Apollo's answer constitute the
prologos.
2. Epeissodes: the developing scenes
3. Exodus: the final concluding scene.
Athena's final investment of the Furies with their new role
constitute the exodus.
Return to top
E. Beatrice Batson's Definition of Tragedy |

|
| Batson defines tragedy as
the following: "Tragedy is a narrative form of literature in which a tragic
protagonist, who possesses greatness of spirit, commits himself to an undertaking of great
magnitude within a given situation and, as a result, comes to spiritual suffering usually
followed by perception and death and possibly by 'redemption.' "(214) |
Batson's definition has
the following elements:
- a narrative form of literature
- protagonist who possess greatness of spirit [Batson does not mean
that the protagonist is necessarily admirable for all he or she does, but rather that the
hero is elevated in human potential.]
- protagonist commits himself or herself to an undertaking of great
magnitude
- protagonist comes to spiritual suffering {Keep in mind that
"spiritual" need not be "holy" here.]
- the suffering is usually followed by perception and death
- possibly, the suffering results in redemption
|
Return to top
Is Orestes the hero of The Eumenides? |
s
|
Is Athena or Apollo?
Is Athens itself a kind of hero? |
| Tragic
protagonist w/ greatness of spirit |
Orestes
is obedient to the will of the gods Perhaps we can understand him as courageous. |
Apollo
comes to the defense of Orestes Athena is dignified and wise in her judicial judgment. |
Athens as a city is great in its democratic nature,
though flawed by the past. |
| Undertaking of great magnitude |
Orestes, after avenging his father, flees to the seat of justice |
Apollo
opposes the FuriesAthena works to guarantee justice and appease the Furies |
Athens seeks to bring justice to its citizens and prosperity by appeasing
the old and new gods. |
| Spiritual suffering |
Orestes undergoes great loss in his obedience to the gods |
Apollo
?Athena? |
Athens suffers in its search to balance the old code of familial
vengeance with its new need for principled law |
| perception and death(redemption) |
Orestes learns that the gods will vindicate the just, obedient person |
Apollo?Athena perceives
that the old law of fury can be subsumed with the new law of respect for the earth.
The Furies are
"redeemed" for the prosperity of Athens |
Athens learns that trial by jury can result in a practical (if
admittedly contestable) process of appeal for crimes. |
Return to top
|